Thursday, July 16, 2009

I have solved the cookie condundrum!!!

I have cracked the code!! It took 3 different recipes and about 40-50 cookies, but I have found the ultimate copycat M&M cookie that the mall sells!! You wouldn't believe how difficult it was to have to sample all of those cookies! Wes and Preston helped and I'm sure they are now exhausted. Also, I'm sure Wes is beloved at the office because I sent him with about 30 cookies today.
I started last night because I was just too excited to wait and made two out of the three recipes last night. I went to bed disappointed because neither recipe was the exact taste I was looking for. Don't get me wrong...they were very yummy, just not the cookie I remember from the mall. I thought maybe my standards were too high. Afterall, look at the runners up:

The one on the left tasted great, just more like a chocolate chip cookie with M&M's instead. The cookie on the right was closer to what I was looking for but lacked the buttery flavor and they were too fluffy. The cookie I like is pretty thin and is about the size as if you put your thumb and forefinger together to get a circle.

This morning, I woke up renewed, determined to see if this cookie would just remain illusive. I took them out of the oven and right away I knew I had found my baby. I could recognize them just by the smell. It brought back memories of Lindsay and I in Crossroads Mall after getting one of those cookie at Great American Cookie Co.

Here's a picture of my babies: Aren't they gorgeous???



And now here's the recipe to Granny's Cookies (hehe)

Granny's Cookies

2 1/4 cups all-purpose flour, fluffed to aerate before measuring

1 teaspoon table salt

1 1/8 teaspoons baking soda

1 cup (2 sticks) unsalted butter at room temperature

1 cup white sugar

1/2 cup brown sugar, golden or dark

1 generous teaspoon vanilla

2 eggs

M&M's, 6 per cookie

Preheat oven to 375. In a small bowl, stir together flour, salt and baking soda. In a large bowl, cream butter and sugars with an electric mixer until creamy. Add vanilla, then one at a time, the eggs, mixing well after each. Mix in flour mixture until fully combined.

Spray a baking sheet with cooking spray. Form balls a tad smaller than a golf ball and arrange well apart (at least 2 inches) on a baking sheet. Place in the oven for about 9 minutes. Remove and lightly place M&M's on top. Return to oven for 3-5 minutes. Remove from oven and let cool before transferring them to a cooling rack.

Stacy's tips: The website I found this on is www.kitchenparade.com and in the comments section, a lot of people said they had problems with their cookies running into each other because they thinned out too much. Because of this, I did a test cookie first and I didn't have any problem with them running. I did put parchment paper on my baking sheets since I was doing so many batches so I don't know if that made a difference.

Also, I cooked mine about a minute less than stated. I made a half batch of this recipe so if you don't want a million cookies on your hands then this is what I would do. I think a half recipe made 18 big cookies.

If you make these cookies and love them like I do, let me know!! Also if you make them and hate them, let me know and I will erase you from my life completely. Hehe. Enjoy!!!

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

My stomach aches just seeing pictures of these. I'm pretty sure I've eaten about 10 cookies so far! - Wes

Cheryl said...

Sorry my cookie recipe wasn't "The One," however, I prefer a thicker, moist cookie, so I can see we disagree a bit on the perfect M&M cookie:) To each her own. Love reading your blog.

The Cooks said...

Cheryl, it was close and if I hadn't been looking for a recreation of one yours would have been it! It was very good!! Thanks for passing it along and I'm going to have to start trying out some of the recipes from your blog! I didn't know you had a food blog. It was making me hungry just looking at it!

Melissa Wisley said...

I am so going to try to bake these this weekend and let you know what I think. I have been dying to bake something anyway! Glad you found your perfect cookie and for sharing the recipe!
Miss you guys! Everytime I wear the white tank top you loaned me that says "filled with love" on it I think of you because everyone always complements that tank. Thanks for letting me borrow your clothes.